NotebookLM
- Some Strengths
- Notebook app that allows you to upload sources and ask Chatbot questions based on those uploaded documents
- Chatbot responses are grounded in the information you provide
- Chatbot provides citations for its responses (i.e., it highlights where in the documents you uploaded it drew its information)
- Great for summarizing uploaded notes and extracting key concepts
- Some Limitations
- Chatbot cannot search the web (it's limited to searching the documents you upload)
- Can only upload PDFs or Google Docs, or copy and paste text
- Limited to 20 document uploads
Research Rabbit
- Some Strengths
- Finds related articles based on citation networks, and provides visualizations of these networks
- Works best if you already have at least one relevant article in mind (i.e., a "seed article")
- Can upload an RIS or BibTeX of relevant articles to analyze
- All features are free!
- Some Limitations
- Metadata for articles can have errors (e.g., listed authors are sometimes incorrect)
- Not all articles are scholarly (e.g., it sometimes retrieves things like libguides!)
- Limited to articles available in Semantic Scholar or PubMed
NLM's LitSuggest
- Some Strengths:
- Model you can train to alert you to new records in PubMed, ranked by relevancy to your topic
- Allows you to tag records as relevant or irrelevant to better train the model
- Allows you to download records marked as relevant and/or irrelevant
- Great for helping you stay up to date on topics of interest
- Some Limitations:
- Takes a long time to load
- Need to have already compiled at least 10 relevant studies to train the model
- Limited to records in PubMed
Microsoft Copilot, ChatGPT, and Gemini
- Some Strengths:
- Chatbots answer questions using information from the web or inputted data
- Great for summarizing and outlining inputted information
- Great for brainstorming ideas
- Can be used to identify search terms
- Some Limitations:
- Susceptible to hallucinations
- No quality control in the sources from which it extracts information for its responses (unless you tell it to only base its responses on information you input)
- Doesn't always cite the sources it uses for its responses (or sometimes makes up citations)
- Information in its responses may be outdated
- Note: The University of Wisconsin-Madison has a subscription to Microsoft Copilot. You can learn more about the subscription here.
Elicit
- Some Strengths
- Retrieves and summarizes literature on a query
- Provides a summary that integrates the top 4 retrieved papers (for the free version), and extracts information from individual articles (e.g., main findings, methodology, intervention, etc.)
- Can extract information from uploaded PDFs
- Has a chatbot which you can ask questions about a paper
- Some Limitations
- Not all articles are scholarly (e.g., it sometimes retrieves things like libguides!)
- Isn't always reliable when extracting information from articles (especially for articles where it only has access to the abstract)
- Searches are not transparent (searches wouldn't be reproducible or comprehensive enough for something like a systematic or scoping review)
SciSpace
- Some Strengths
- Retrieves and summarizes literature on a query
- Provides a summary that integrates the top 5 retrieved papers (for the free version), and extracts information from individual articles (e.g., limitations, conclusions, methods, etc.)
- Can extract information from uploaded PDFs
- Has a chatbot where you can ask questions about a paper
- Some Limitations
- Limited usage for a free account (e.g., only 5 searches per day)
- Metadata for articles can have errors (e.g., listed authors are sometimes incorrect)
- Searches are not transparent (searches wouldn't be reproducible or comprehensive enough for something like a systematic or scoping review)
Perplexity
- Some Strengths:
- Chatbot that answers questions using sources from the web
- Provides links to sources it uses in the query
- Great for finding webpages about a topic
- Some Limitations:
- Sources are typically non-scholarly
- Only provides a few sources per query
For a list of additional AI tools, see Ithaka S+R's Generative AI Product Tracker.